Nie wywołuj wilka z lasu, Polska – on a possible exemption provided to Israeli politicians from the ICC

There are news going around the Polish government possibly granting immunity for official Israeli visitors from arrest and extradition to the ICC. Although the news is currently quite ambiguous (there has been no concrete announcement from Netanyahu about a visit to Poland), it is important to state that a state party to the Rome Statute cannot validly guarantee such immunities – the Statute contains the obligation to arrest and surrender without any exceptions.

Although the absurdity of the situation is indisputable – namely the idea that the Israeli Prime Minister arriving for the Auschwitz memorial service should face the risk of arrest – the ICC arrest warrant is not a political product, and accordingly, it does not take such aspects into account.

Poland, however, must take into account its existing obligations, and these are clear under the Statute.

Personally, I think that Netanyahu will not travel to Poland, what we are seeing now is nothing more than a “rumble” taking place in the Polish political communication space – the first to speak on the subject was President Duda, who has absolutely no problem putting Prime Minister Donald Tusk in a difficult position. The latter has to respond to this, while having to be very careful not to alienate his country from either the Western allies, the EU or the International Criminal Court itself, which has/will have an important role in the ongoing Russian-Ukrainian war, itself as a kind of “ally”, with the arrest warrant issued against Putin.

Told You so…? ICC and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict

As I recently indicated, the ICC seemingly paves the way of jurisdiction to weight in the Israeli-Palestinian confict – following its footsteps made in the situation related to the persecution of the Rohingya, related to Mianmar.

The Prosecutor yesterday announced her decision to initiate investigations as preliminary examinations are concluded, and according to her opinion, the ICC has jurisdiction on the case. Now the Pre-Trial Chamber has to make a decision on this, expectedly there are going to be arguments from Israel against this… We are looking forward to a potentially historical decision by the ICC at a later point.

The persecution of the Rohingya is now being addressed not only by the ICJ but also by the ICC

Legal developments concerning the crimes committed against the Rohingya – which could easily be classified as genocide – have accelerated. As I indicated a few days ago, an inter-state case has been filed against Myanmar before the International Court of Justice. Furthermore, yesterday, the International Criminal Court announced its decision to authorize the Prosecutor to conduct an investigation into the matter. Consequently, formal indictments may be issued; in addition to the aforementioned inter-state case, specific criminal proceedings could now take place before this other judicial body in The Hague.

A notable aspect of this case is that it marks the first time in the history of ICC that a state affected by the investigation is not a party to the Rome Statutue of 1998 (the founding treaty of the ICC) that governs the court’s operations. Moreover, the investigation was not initiated by the UN Security Council – as was the case previously with Sudan and Libya – but rather at the initiative of the court’s own prosecutor (which is why a judicial decision was required to grant approval). Until now, such actions had only involved states that were parties to the treaty; logically, as the founding treaty cointans no provision for such proceedings being possible regarding non-party states. The crux of the matter is the Prosecutor’s argument that the international crimes committed against the Muslim Rohingya minority – who lived within the territory of Myanmar – do also affect Bangladesh, a state party – and in the border region it is not even entirely clear, where the acts were actually committed. In essence, consequently, the ICC is now is exercising its jurisdiction in relation to Bangladesh, a state party.

While this is certainly a very extensive interpretation of the scope of the jurisdiction of the ICC, the fact of the authorisation of the Pre-Trial Chambermakes it to become a reality. For those who study or observe international criminal law – especially those focused on its impact on international relations – the next question will be: when will this interpretation find its way to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict?